Before the cutesy invasion of trite quote wall signs, we
relied on coffee cups to express our inner snark. I remember I used to have a
favorite mug with big white letters that read, “if you are what you eat, then I
am fast, cheap and easy.” Pondering our relationship to information, media, and
news these days makes me think of that coffee mug. Everything these days
centers on easy and fast. The speed at which information comes at us isn’t
geared to generate thoughtful analysis but instead offers bite sized nuggets of
news to be scarfed down on the way to the next thing. Society likes to cast
blame on technology, but our cultural values created the consumption habits not
the mechanisms we use. I could spend all day pondering how we got here, but as professional
educators the objective is to empower the next generation of solutions for information
literacy.
The workload of a school librarian involves so many layers
of responsibilities to create and support curriculum for students and staff.
The urgency to help students become more involved in their own educational
process as critical consumers of information seems to grow with every new
report of false or biased news media. The “Framework for Information Literacy for
Higher Education” from the ACLR aims to create more definitive guidelines for
how to implement more inquiry and research-based learning approaches (2015). One
of the key concepts in the ACLP framework is the described as, “scholarship as conversation”
(2015). Seeking out perspectives other
than our own is such a critical component of understanding complex problems. We
all bring to the table own ideas and expectations when we engage in dialog or receive
information. When we start to filter out divisions of opinions from the sources
we receive information, the imbalances can limit our ability to discover new insights.
Identifying our own lens filters as teachers and human beings is great starting
point when we consider how to teach students the value of evaluating
information and biases.
The list of 21st Century Student Outcomes from the
framework definitions spans your standard school subjects and then spans across
broader concepts such as global awareness, financial literacy, public health
concerns and civic implications (2015). These once higher-level learning topics
are impacting children earlier and with greater ramifications, therefore need
to addressed even at even younger ages than we do now.
We can’t skip over the
foundational ideas of information seeking behaviors in our own environments. It
takes significantly more time to really assess the quality of information we
are sharing with students rather than just what is expedient in the face of
busy school days. Practices that require both teachers and students to use
various research methods, assess for strengths and weaknesses while examining
conflicting information, are vital elements to the information literacy process
(ALA, 2015). The shift for me is away from the “us versus them mentality” that
is pervasive in making ideas wrong or right. I don’t want to be right anymore. I
want to understand. I want to hear and listen. I want to be a part of exploring
ideas and concepts with students so that we can slow down the rush on the next
thing. I hope we can stop treating education and learning like a trip to Wendy’s
and more like a five-star meal made with quality and attention.
American Library Association, (2015). Framework for Information Literacy for Higher Education", http://www.ala.org/acrl/standards/ilframework (Accessed September 1, 2021) Document ID: b910a6c4-6c8a-0d44-7dbc-a5dcbd509e3f
P21 Framework Definitions (2015) Framework for 21st
Century Learning. https://www.battelleforkids.org/networks/p21/frameworks-resources

This was the read I didn't know I needed this morning. The introductory paragraph was spot on and made me have to clean the water I was drinking off of the computer screen. We had our fair share snark on ceramic art in our kitchen as well.
ReplyDeleteI find that I am one to blame technology, particularly social media for the misinformation that I hear and see people spouting, and I don't know that I an be convinced to abandon that concept just yet. I had never connected the dots to the fact that our lifestyle lends itself to falling victim to this. Everything is a "now" mentality. There is no patience, there is no enjoying the ride. Its more, faster, now. Taking time to critically evaluate sources takes time. Reading more than just the headline and the opening paragraph takes time. So how do we get students, who never knew life before the fast-paced tech evolution that we have seen in our lifetime, to stop and smell the roses, enjoy the ride, and take their time in consuming information? That is a thought that is going to require more pondering and much skill to make a reality, but I can't think of any place better to start to chip away at the iceburg than in my library. One information consumer at a time.
So glad to have fellow kitchen snark art enthusiast here. I know it is out of fashion, but I am in it for the long haul and will be ready when the trend wave rides back.
DeleteI definitely share the concern for misinformation that has been given a bull horn online. I was actually surprised the other day when I went to share on twitter an article I had read online, but gave me a notice that I was sharing something that the system showed I hadn't read yet. I had actually read it previously, but I felt somewhat buoyed that it offered a reminder not to share something without reading it.
Keep chipping at the iceberg!
I love your introduction as well. Your "fast, easy, and cheap" quote reminded me of our reading this week. So many educators are looking for the fastest way to teach content, but that is almost never the be best way. I agree with your last paragraph. So much of the media divide and sensationalized news is due to the us versus them thought process. Listening to others perspectives and learning about other points of view is great for empathy and understanding.
ReplyDeleteThanks Kristina. That narrative of division is not a new tool for sure, but certainly feels like its been weaponized in the information age. Absolutely agree that empathy and expanding our perspective is a truly effective way to counter act it.
Delete"I don’t want to be right anymore. I want to understand. I want to hear and listen. I want to be a part of exploring ideas and concepts with students so that we can slow down the rush on the next thing." I love this quote from your last paragraph. I admit when I think about the media and technology consumption of the people I love, it makes me really, really tired. I am tired of feeling like I have to debunk or refute the inaccurate news they share. I think slowing down and not wanting to be right brings a small sense of relief.
ReplyDeleteI also agree with your statement that technology did not build this situation, rather our cultural values did. I wonder, then, how we might use technology to help teach the slower, more careful learning and collaboration you mention in this post. And how can we counter in our classrooms and libraries the "fast and cheap" values being taught and modeled elsewhere?
Nicholette, the exhaustion from it all is so very real. It makes me think of all the moments in great action adventure books when the protagonists are feeling all down and out and hopeless in their dilemmas. i love that lightbulb moment when they flip the script and use the problem to their advantage. They stop letting the villains define their actions and find unexpected solutions. I feel like there is opportunity to flip the script and rewrite out relationship to technology. I see so many ways we can teach children innovative paths to find authenticity and genuine connections thru technology but it will definitely require new approaches to how we teach and use it the classroom. Those small moments of pause and relief matter. The pause allows space for us to see the possibilities. It is one of the reasons I love these classes and field so much. Thanks for sharing your thoughts with me.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete